Robinhood v Fidelity | Who is the better broker?

In this detailed summary, we explore the essential differences between two popular brokerage firms: Fidelity and Robinhood. Having invested with both for over six years, we will analyze key categories crucial for investors making a choice between these platforms. The evaluation will focus on safety, user interface, investment and trading experience, and cryptocurrency services.

---

The Categories of Comparison

1. Safety
   Both Fidelity and Robinhood offer investment safety features. Here’s a brief breakdown:
   • Fidelity:
     • FDIC Insured: Up to $250,000.
     • Additional Coverage: Lloyd’s of London insurance covers excess up to $1 billion.
   • Robinhood:
     • FDIC Insured: Up to $250,000.
     • Additional Coverage: Lloyd’s policy caps at $100 million, with $10.5 million per customer.
   • Grade: Both firms received an A for safety due to robust backup policies and federal insurance.
2. User Interface
   The usability and intuitiveness of platforms differ significantly:
   • Fidelity:
     • Focuses on detailed data and numerous tabs, perfect for data-heavy investors but could overwhelm casual users.
     • Grade: B- due to its complex interface.
   • Robinhood:
     • An intuitive, user-friendly mobile application that simplifies navigation and provides quick feedback on stock performance.
     • Grade: A for its sleek design and fast usability.
3. Investment and Trading Experience
   A clear distinction arises in the research and trading resources available:
   • Fidelity:
     • Offers comprehensive research tools, detailed stock pages, extensive investment reports, and an advanced stock screener.
     • Grade: A for its depth and quality of information.
   • Robinhood:
     • While easy to use, it lacks in-depth research tools and offers limited stock charts, making it less suitable for serious investors.
     • Grade: D for inadequate research support.
4. Cryptocurrency Services
   The evolution of cryptocurrency offerings is noteworthy:
   • Fidelity:
     • Recently launched its crypto platform but currently offers only Bitcoin and Ethereum trading, with limitations on access and custodial control, resulting in a D grade.
   • Robinhood:
     • Facilitates trading in 18 cryptocurrencies and allows users to transfer crypto to external wallets. It also has effective educational features regarding cryptocurrencies.
     • Grade: B for robust cryptocurrency offerings.

---

Conclusion

After thorough analysis, we see that both firms carry unique advantages and drawbacks:

Category	Fidelity Grade	Robinhood Grade
Safety	A	A
User Interface	B-	A
Investment and Trading Experience	A	D
Cryptocurrency	D	B

Final Grade Summary

• Fidelity: B- (2.93 GPA)
• Robinhood: B

While Fidelity excels in research and investment tools, Robinhood provides a fast and user-friendly interface, appealing to casual traders. Ultimately, the choice between these platforms depends on personal preference—whether prioritizing in-depth analysis or ease of trading. Both remain safe options for investors.

requently Asked Questions about Robinhood

1. Can I use Robinhood in South Africa?No, Robinhood is not available in South Africa. The platform primarily serves U.S. residents and does not accept clients from South Africa.
   Broker Xperts
2. What is the downside of Robinhood?While Robinhood offers commission-free trading, it has several drawbacks:
   • Limited Investment Options: Robinhood does not support certain retirement accounts like Roth IRAs, which offer tax-free growth.
     Consumer Affairs
   • Customer Service Concerns: Users have reported challenges with customer support, including long response times and difficulty resolving issues.
   • Hidden Costs: Some studies suggest that Robinhood’s options trading may involve hidden costs that could be higher than those of other brokers.
     The Wall Street Journal
3. What countries is Robinhood available in?As of now, Robinhood is only available to residents of the United States. It does not accept clients from other countries, including South Africa.
   Broker Xperts
4. How trustworthy is Robinhood?Robinhood is a regulated brokerage firm in the U.S., adhering to financial industry standards. However, it has faced criticism over issues like platform outages during high volatility periods and concerns about payment for order flow practices. While generally considered trustworthy, potential users should be aware of these controversies.
5. How to withdraw money from Robinhood immediately?To withdraw funds from your Robinhood account:
   • Navigate to the “Account” tab.
   • Select “Transfers” and then “Transfer to Your Bank.”
   • Enter the amount you wish to withdraw and confirm the transaction.

   Please note that while Robinhood processes withdrawals promptly, the actual time for funds to appear in your bank account may vary depending on your bank’s processing times.

6. Do you make money on Robinhood?Yes, you can make money on Robinhood through various investment options, including stocks, ETFs, options, and cryptocurrencies. However, investing carries inherent risks, and it’s possible to lose money. It’s essential to conduct thorough research and consider your financial goals and risk tolerance before investing.